Jan 14, 2015, 09:00
by
Michael Croft
Eric Topol, The Patient Will See You Now; The Future of Medicine is in Your Hands, New York: Basic Books, 2015
Review by Mary Chitty
January 14, 2015 | Eric Topol is a
Scripps Translational Science Institute cardiologist and self-professed technophile, but this is not just a book about
technologies. Rather The
Patient Will See You Now argues that patient
engagement and the end of medical paternalism are key components of 21st
century healthcare.
Topol’s
previous book, The Creative Destruction of Medicine: How the digital
revolution will create better health care, discussed the large number of
patients for whom “one size fits all” medications are ineffective (or toxic).
In Creative Destruction, Topol
provided a nuanced assessment of the role sequencing will play in the
increasingly intertwined fields of diagnostics and therapeutics, but the
increasing presence of the patient will just as dramatically change medicine.
Technologies—especially smartphones and wearable
sensors—offer cheaper and more ubiquitous diagnostic and monitoring
capabilities, accessible even to the homeless and people in developing
countries. Topol does not shy away from complex issues such as the challenges
of data privacy, security, and sharing.
The patient has never been more isolated or more
connected than now.
Equipped with electronic medical records and
health information technology, we are beginning to better able detect
individual drug toxicities, which rarely emerge until drugs are used in large
numbers of patients after clinical trials.
Complex chronic diseases are an increasing part
of medical needs (and costs). There are tradeoffs as we make progress in curing
or preventing diseases. The remarkable twentieth century increase in average
lifespans is tied to the increase in late onset dementia.
Topol recognizes that overuse of antibiotics
leads to drug resistance, and particularly dangerous nocosomial infections in
hospitals. Overuse of medical imaging can result in potentially carcinogenic
radiation exposure, which can be somewhat mitigated by electronic medical
records and less need to repeat previous tests. And overuse of diagnostic tests
leads to false positives and findings of incidental or unknown significance.
The US spends more on healthcare than any other
country, often with indifferent results. Finding the appropriate balance between
interventions and watchful waiting, respecting patient priorities and autonomy,
while providing guidance (and comfort) when prevention and cure are not options
is and will continue to be challenging.
Perhaps the greatest challenges ahead—both for
patients and health professionals—will be learning to manage uncertainty and
expectations.
This is a well-documented and thoughtful look at
current and future medicine. It is complemented by books such as Atul Gawande’s
Being Mortal: What Matters in the End.
(Metropolitan, 2014)
Mortality—and nothing else—is still 100% certain.
Editor's note: Books may be sent to the review editor for consideration at 250 First Ave. Ste 300, Needham, MA 02494